Home warranty rankings

Home warranty company rankings

Six honest ways to compare 19 companies, all built from public Better Business Bureau and Trustpilot data, plus published plan pricing (data current as of June 2026). Nobody pays to rank higher.

How these boards are built

Six rankings over 19 home-warranty companies: Reliability Score, BBB reviews, Trustpilot, BBB letter grade, longevity, and starting plan price, with no paid placements.

Each board is computed from public BBB and Trustpilot fields plus published plan pricing. Home-warranty issuers are not CFPB-regulated, so complaint databases are not used. Open a board for the full ordered list and the ranking formula.

According to the Better Business Bureau and Trustpilot's public review databases, these rankings are computed directly from each company's current rating and review counts. See our methodology for how each ranking is built.

Most Reliable

Companies ranked by our Reliability Score, BBB rating, BBB reviews, and Trustpilot, blended transparently.

See all →
  1. 1 HomeServe A
  2. 2 Old Republic Home Protection A
  3. 3 Liberty Home Guard 2 of 3 signals A
  4. 4 America's Preferred Home Warranty A
  5. 5 AFC Home Club B

Highest BBB Reviews

Ranked by Better Business Bureau customer-review average (minimum 50 reviews).

See all →
  1. 1 HomeServe A
  2. 2 Liberty Home Guard 2 of 3 signals A
  3. 3 AFC Home Club B
  4. 4 Old Republic Home Protection A
  5. 5 First Premier Home Warranty D

Most Trusted on Trustpilot

Ranked by Trustpilot TrustScore (minimum 50 reviews).

See all →
  1. 1 America's Preferred Home Warranty A
  2. 2 HomeServe A
  3. 3 Liberty Home Guard 2 of 3 signals A
  4. 4 Old Republic Home Protection A
  5. 5 AFC Home Club B

Best BBB Ratings

Ranked by the BBB letter rating, from A+ down.

See all →
  1. 1 HomeServe A
  2. 2 Old Republic Home Protection A
  3. 3 America's Preferred Home Warranty A
  4. 4 Cinch Home Services B
  5. 5 Fidelity National Home Warranty C

Longest-Operating

The most established providers, by founding year.

See all →
  1. 1 American Home Shield C
  2. 2 Old Republic Home Protection A
  3. 3 Fidelity National Home Warranty C
  4. 4 Cinch Home Services B
  5. 5 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty C

Most Affordable Plans

Ranked by starting annual plan cost, lowest first.

See all →
  1. 1 HomeServe A
  2. 2 American Home Shield C
  3. 3 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty C
  4. 4 Porch Home Warranty 1 of 3 signals F
  5. 5 Cinch Home Services B

Score basis. A Reliability Score normally blends three signals, and a review signal counts once a company has 5 reviews. 2 companies here rest on fewer, so their scores carry less evidence than the rest of the table: Liberty Home Guard: BBB reviews and Trustpilot only (BBB profile not rated); Porch Home Warranty: BBB rating only (0 BBB reviews, 2 Trustpilot reviews). How the score is built.

Source: Better Business Bureau and Trustpilot, plus company plan documents. Home-warranty companies are not CFPB-regulated, so no CFPB data is used.

Every figure on PlainWarranty is rendered directly from BBB, Trustpilot, and state regulatory data, no number is typed in by an editor. Rankings are computed directly from BBB, Trustpilot, and state regulatory data, no figure is typed in by an editor. See our editorial standards & corrections policy, the methodology behind these numbers, or report a data error.