Most Trusted Home Warranty Companies (Trustpilot)
Companies ranked by their Trustpilot TrustScore (minimum 50 reviews).
America's Preferred Home Warranty leads on trustscore at 4.90★ across 964 reviews, against a cohort median of 4.00★ (+0.90★ vs median). Only companies with at least 50 reviews appear here; even above that floor, a few new ratings can move an average, so treat the #1 spot as directional rather than definitive.
Most Trusted Home Warranty Companies (Trustpilot)
Ranked by trustscore · floor ≥50 reviews · top 12
| # | Company | Grade | TrustScore |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | America's Preferred Home Warranty | A | 4.90★ |
| 2 | HomeServe | A | 4.70★ |
| 3 | Liberty Home Guard | A | 4.50★ |
| 4 | Old Republic Home Protection | A | 4.20★ |
| 5 | AFC Home Club | B | 4.10★ |
| 6 | Cinch Home Services | B | 4.00★ |
| 7 | First American Home Warranty | B | 4.00★ |
| 8 | Choice Home Warranty | C | 4.00★ |
| 9 | Home Warranty of America | C | 4.00★ |
| 10 | American Home Shield | C | 3.90★ |
| 11 | ServicePlus Home Warranty | C | 3.50★ |
| 12 | Select Home Warranty | C | 2.90★ |
| 13 | First Premier Home Warranty | D | 2.30★ |
| 14 | 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty | C | 1.50★ |
| 15 | Landmark Home Warranty | C | 1.40★ |
| 16 | Total Home Protection | D | 1.20★ |
Source: Trustpilot.
What this ranking tells you
This ranking orders companies by their Trustpilot TrustScore (out of 5), among companies with at least 50 reviews. The denominator floor and the cohort median on this page keep thin profiles from looking like category leaders. Trustpilot review profiles often skew more positive than BBB reviews because companies actively invite satisfied customers to review there. A high Trustpilot score paired with a strong BBB rating is the most reassuring combination; a high Trustpilot score next to a weak BBB rating warrants a closer look at the contract.
No single ranking captures a company in full. A provider that tops one axis can sit mid-pack on another, strong BBB complaint-handling alongside soft customer reviews, say. The best decision reads several of these lists together and intersects them with the company detail pages for coverage, pricing, and state availability.
Frequently asked questions
How reliable is a Trustpilot score?
Trustpilot scores reflect customers who chose to leave a review, and companies can solicit reviews, so scores can skew positive. Review volume matters: we require at least 50 reviews to appear here, and we still show the count beside each score because a 4.5 from thousands of reviews is more meaningful than a 4.9 from barely 50.
Explore more rankings
Source: Better Business Bureau & Trustpilot Home warranty company ratings and customer reviews · 2026 Reputation figures are point-in-time snapshots; rankings recompute as the underlying data is refreshed.
Read our methodology - how the Reliability Score is sourced and computed.
Every figure on PlainWarranty is rendered directly from BBB, Trustpilot, and state regulatory data, no number is typed in by an editor. Rankings are computed directly from BBB, Trustpilot, and state regulatory data, no figure is typed in by an editor. See our editorial standards & corrections policy, the methodology behind these numbers, or report a data error.