Home Warranty Company Rankings

Companies ranked by complaint data, response quality, and affordability. All rankings use CFPB consumer complaint data and public records.

Best Overall Companies

Home warranty companies ranked by our composite score: response rates, complaints, and customer satisfaction.

See all →
  1. 1 America's Preferred Home Warranty BBB A+
  2. 2 Old Republic Home Protection BBB A-
  3. 3 Fidelity National Home Warranty BBB A-
  4. 4 Landmark Home Warranty BBB A-
  5. 5 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty BBB B

Most Consumer Complaints

Companies with the highest total complaint volume from CFPB data.

See all →
  1. 1 American Home Shield BBB B
  2. 2 Choice Home Warranty BBB B
  3. 3 First American Home Warranty BBB A
  4. 4 Select Home Warranty BBB B
  5. 5 Cinch Home Services BBB B

Best Response Rates

Companies that respond to consumer complaints most promptly.

See all →
  1. 1 America's Preferred Home Warranty BBB A+
  2. 2 Old Republic Home Protection BBB A-
  3. 3 Fidelity National Home Warranty BBB A-
  4. 4 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty BBB B
  5. 5 Landmark Home Warranty BBB A-

Lowest Dispute Rates

Companies where consumers least often dispute the company response.

See all →
  1. 1 America's Preferred Home Warranty BBB A+
  2. 2 Old Republic Home Protection BBB A-
  3. 3 Fidelity National Home Warranty BBB A-
  4. 4 Landmark Home Warranty BBB A-
  5. 5 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty BBB B

Most Affordable Plans

Companies ranked by annual plan cost — best value for budget-conscious homeowners.

See all →
  1. 1 Porch Home Warranty BBB B-
  2. 2 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty BBB B
  3. 3 American Home Shield BBB B
  4. 4 Landmark Home Warranty BBB A-
  5. 5 First Premier Home Warranty BBB B