Home Warranty Company Comparison

All 19 companies ranked by complaint score. Lower complaints and higher response rates = better score.

#	Company	Score	Complaints	Timely	Disputed	BBB	Annual Cost	Est. 2026
1	America's Preferred Home Warranty	B	1,200	95%	6%	A+	$450-$600	100,000+
2	Old Republic Home Protection	C	3,100	93%	10%	A-	$400-$700	400,000+
3	Fidelity National Home Warranty	C	2,200	92%	11%	A-	$350-$600	200,000+
4	Landmark Home Warranty	C	1,400	91%	11%	A-	$350-$550	100,000+
5	2-10 Home Buyers Warranty	C	4,200	92%	12%	B	$300-$700	500,000+
6	HSA Home Warranty	C	2,600	90%	13%	B+	$450-$700	200,000+
7	First American Home Warranty	C	8,400	91%	14%	A	$350-$600	500,000+
8	HomeServe	C	3,800	90%	14%	B+	$50-$300 per plan	5,000,000+
9	Cinch Home Services	D	5,500	88%	16%	B	$350-$700	400,000+
10	AFC Home Club	D	900	86%	17%	A	$400-$750	100,000+
11	American Home Shield	D	24,850	89%	18%	B	$300-$900	2,000,000+
12	Liberty Home Guard	D	2,800	87%	19%	A	$400-$700	200,000+
13	Home Warranty of America	D	1,900	84%	20%	B-	$400-$600	100,000+
14	Porch Home Warranty	D	600	83%	21%	B-	$300-$500	50,000+
15	Choice Home Warranty	D	19,200	85%	22%	B	$450-$650	1,000,000+
16	First Premier Home Warranty	D	400	80%	24%	B	$350-$550	20,000+
17	Select Home Warranty	D	6,800	82%	25%	B	$400-$600	300,000+
18	ServicePlus Home Warranty	D	1,800	78%	28%	C+	$400-$600	100,000+
19	Total Home Protection	D	1,500	75%	30%	C	$400-$600	50,000+